Revisiting the Notion of Being a Cafeteria Catholic

Somewhere in my growing up years, I heard that pejorative term "Cafeteria Catholic" which refers to one who picks and chooses one's doctrinal beliefs and practices from the sacred smorgasbord found within that centuries old dining establishment, the Deposit of Faith. The idea, supported by those hard-core members who dined there, was to eat what was set before you...all of it! You'd better not question, comment upon nor complain about what the cooks put out that day either. The expectation too was that you'd better clean your plate because there were starving people in other denominations and religions who didn't have the privilege of tucking in for such a beneficial time of gestational fortification. This topic came up last night during the panel discussion that followed the showing of the movie, "Building A Bridge" featuring the ministry of Fr. James Martin, the intrepid Jesuit priest whose heart longs to see the church embrace and honor her LGBT ...